First Internet Bancorp (NASDAQ:INBK) Q3 2023 Earnings Conference Call October 26, 2023 2:00 PM ET
Company Participants
Larry Clark – Senior Vice President, Financial Profiles, Inc.
David Becker – Chairman and Chief Executive Officer
Ken Lovik – Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer
Conference Call Participants
Nathan Race – Piper Sandler
George Sutton – Craig-Hallum
John Rodis – Janney
Brett Rabatin – Hovde Group
Operator
Good day, ladies and gentlemen, and welcome to the First Internet Bancorp Third Quarter 2023 Earnings Conference Call. At this time, all lines are in listen-only mode. Following the presentation, we’ll conduct a question-and-answer session. [Operator Instructions] This call is being recorded today, October 26, 2023.
I will now like to turn the conference over to Larry Clark from Financial Profiles, Inc. Please go ahead, Mr. Clark.
Larry Clark
Thank you, Sergio. Good day, everyone, and thank you for joining us to discuss First Internet Bancorp’s financial results for the third quarter of 2023. The company issued its earnings press release yesterday afternoon, and it’s available on the company’s website. In addition, the company has included a slide presentation that you can refer to during the call. You can also access these slides on the website. Joining us today from the management team are Chairman and CEO, David Becker; and Executive Vice President and CFO, Ken Lovik. David will provide an overview, and Ken will discuss the financial results. Then we’ll open up the call to your questions.
Before we begin, I’d like to remind you that this conference call contains forward-looking statements with respect to the future performance and financial condition of First Internet Bancorp that involve risks and uncertainties. Various factors could cause actual results to materially be different from any future results expressed or implied by such forward-looking statements. These factors are discussed in the company’s SEC filings, which are available on the company’s website. The company disclaims any obligation to update any forward-looking statements made during the call. Additionally, management may refer to non-GAAP measures, which are intended to supplement but not substitute for the most directly comparable GAAP measures. The press release, available on the website, contains the financial and other quantitative information to be discussed today, as well as a reconciliation of the GAAP to non-GAAP measures.
At this time, I’d like to turn the call over to David.
David Becker
Thank you, Larry. Good afternoon, everyone, and thanks for joining us today as we discuss our third quarter 2023 results. Starting with the highlights on Slide 3, I would like to discuss some key themes for the quarter. We generated strong deposit growth during the quarter, bolstering our liquidity profile and driving down our loan-to-deposit ratio below 92%. We also continued to transition the composition of our loan portfolio and optimize our overall balance sheet mix. As new origination yields were up 50 basis points from the second quarter to 8.92%, and they were up over 360 basis points from the third quarter of 2022. At the same time, both the pace of deposit cost increases and the rate of compression in our net interest margin were the slowest they’ve been in five quarters. Moreover, while one month does not make a trend, we were encouraged by the month-over-month increase in our net interest margin in September.
Recognizing that macroeconomic and geopolitical factors remain outside of our control, we continue to believe that our net interest margin and overall net interest income have likely bottomed out and will follow an upward path from here. Another highlight for the quarter was our SBA team’s continued outstanding performance. The team again posted its highest level of quarterly gain on sale revenue to date, which was up over 14% from the second quarter, driven primarily by a strong increase in the sold loan volume. Following our exit from the consumer mortgage business earlier this year, our mix in non-interest revenue has shifted from what was an overreliance on the cyclicality of the low multiple mortgage business to what we believe is a more consistent, reliable, and growth-oriented revenue stream regardless of the interest rate environment in SBA.
Our nationwide SBA team is doing a great job of providing growth capital to entrepreneurs and small business owners across the country, with year-to-date originations up 165% over the first nine months of 2022. I am especially proud to announce that for the SBA’s fiscal year ended September 30, 2023, we were the ninth largest 7A program lender in the country. This is a notable increase from our ranking of 27th position in the prior fiscal year. We believe that the combination of our continued loan portfolio repositioning and consistent revenue growth from our SBA business positions us well for higher earnings and profitability as deposit costs stabilize.
Our overall credit quality remains strong as non-performing loans to total loans declined to 16 basis points and non-performing assets to total assets declined to 12 basis points. Additional delinquencies 30 days or more were 22 basis points of total loans, while net charge-offs to average loans remained low at 16 basis points. And again, I would like to remind everyone that our exposure to office commercial real estate is less than 1% of our total loan balance and does not include any central business district exposure. Our capital levels remain sound with a common equity Tier 1 capital ratio of 9.59% at quarter end. Our deposit growth resulted in carrying above average cash balances, which we think is prudent to do in the current environment. The impact of higher interest rates also contributed to an increase in the accumulated other comprehensive loss that runs through equity.
These factors weighed on the tangible common equity ratio, however, our capital – regulatory capital ratios at both the company and bank levels remain well above minimum requirements. Tangible common equity was also affected by our share repurchase activity as we repurchased nearly 100,000 shares during the quarter at an average price equating to less than half of our tangible book value per share. I would also like to point out that the prudent conservative management of our investment portfolio and overall balance sheet has resulted in First Internet being among the few banks to have grown tangible book value per share, a key measure of shareholder value creation from the start of this historic cycle of interest rate hikes at the beginning of last year through the end of the most recent quarter.
Now turning to our financial and operating results for the third quarter of 2023, we reported net income of $3.4 million and diluted earnings per share of $0.39. Despite higher funding costs, total revenue was $24.8 million, up from $24 million in the second quarter as the growth in SBA revenue helped to offset a decline in net interest income. Additionally, operating expenses were in line with our expectations given the strong origination and activity in SBA and our non-interest expense to average assets was relatively flat at 1.53%. We produced a healthy 9.6% annualized rate of overall loan growth with gains in franchise finance, construction, small business lending, and consumer. These were offset partially by declines in public finance, healthcare finance, single tenant lease financing, and investor commercial real estate.
As a reminder, the shift in loan mix is the result of a strategic initiative to focus on variable rate, higher yielding products during a historic rapidly rising interest rate. Our construction team had another strong quarter originating almost $180 million in new commitments and producing growth of nearly $60 million in funded balances. At quarter end, total non – unfunded commitments in our construction line of business increased to $527 million, leaving us well positioned to continue shifting the composition of the loan portfolio towards higher yielding variable rate loans. Our consumer lending team also had another solid quarter as the trailers, recreational vehicles, and other consumer loan portfolios were up on a combined basis over $17 million. We remain focused on high quality borrowers and continue to obtain rates on new production in the mid 8% range. Delinquencies in these portfolios remain low as well at just 1 basis point.
And lastly, I want to provide an update on our Banking-as-a-Service and Fintech partnership initiative. In the third quarter, we announced a new relationship with jaris, a leading financial technology provider of fully managed commercial financial solutions for small businesses. Initially, we will provide loan origination services for a large portion of their short-term working capital lending product offered to their client base. We are very impressed with the jaris team and excited about the opportunity. This partnership will enable us to further increase our goal of providing small business owners and entrepreneurs access to capital while maintaining the highest compliance and credit quality standards. It is emblematic of the potential we see for banks and fintechs to partner for positive customer outcomes.
In conclusion, our third quarter results provide us with optimism regarding the outlook for our business. From a safety and soundness perspective, liquidity and credit quality remain very strong and capital levels are sound. With the Federal Reserve rate hikes likely nearing an end, we expect to see a continued decline in the pace of deposit cost increases and eventually stabilization. This combined with a strong performance of our SP18 and a continued improvement in our loan product portfolio composition, leas is well positioned to achieve higher earnings and profitability as we look to 2024 and beyond.
With that, I would like to turn the call over to Ken for more details of our financial results for the quarter.
Ken Lovik
Thanks, David. Now turning to Slide 4, David covered the highlights for the quarter from a lending perspective, so I will just provide some additional color.
Consistent with our focus on variable rate and higher yielding asset classes, we were pleased that our third quarter funded portfolio origination yields continued to increase from the second quarter. Because of the fixed rate nature of some of our larger portfolios, there is a lagging impact of the higher origination yields on the overall loan portfolio. However, as new origination yields have been consistently higher throughout 2023, we expect the overall loan yield to continue to increase in future periods.
Our SBA, construction and franchise finance channels continue to have very strong pipelines. There is one caveat to our outlook on loan pipelines that I will speak to in a little more detail later, that being the possibility of a government shutdown in November and the potential impact on the SBA pipeline. As David just said moments ago, some macroeconomic and geopolitical factors remain outside of our control.
If we avert a shutdown, and similar to what we accomplished in the second and third quarters, our goal is to fund a portion of this production using cash flows from other portfolios as we continue to rebalance and optimize the composition of the total loan portfolio.
Moving on to deposits on slides 5 through 7, deposit balances continued to increase and were up $229 million or 6% from the end of the second quarter. The majority of the deposit growth during the quarter came from CDs with strong demand from consumers and small business. We originated $428 million in new production and renewals during the quarter at an average cost of 5.14% and a weighted average term of 15 months. These were partially offset by maturities of $180 million with an average cost of 3.07%.
Looking forward, we have $276 million of CDs maturing in the fourth quarter with an average cost of 4.34% and $459 million maturing in the first quarter of 2024 with an average cost of 4.62%. So you can see the repricing gap between the cost of new CDs and the cost of maturing CDs is closing, which will contribute significantly to the continued pace of slowing deposit costs.
Non-maturity deposits were down slightly at quarter end as declines in interest-bearing checking and money market balances were offset by an increase in banking-as-a-service deposits driven by higher payments volume. Deposits from our banking-as-a-service partners were up 5% from the second quarter and totaled $162 million at quarter end. Additionally, these partners generated over $3.4 billion in payments volume, which was up 16% from the volume we processed in the second quarter. From a revenue perspective, total banking-as-a-service fees were up 24% quarter-over-quarter, with a large majority of the increase consisting of recurring oversight and transaction fees.
Additionally, broker deposits decreased $12 million from the end of the second quarter as a contractual relationship matured early in the quarter and we continued to reduce higher cost portions of our deposit base. As a result of all the deposit and interest rate activity during the third quarter, the cost of our interest-bearing deposits increased by 34 basis points from the second quarter, which as David mentioned, is the slowest pace of growth over the last five quarters.
In addition to the large volume of CDs maturing over the next two quarters, we also have about $75 million of broker deposits maturing in the fourth quarter with a weighted average cost of almost 5%. Part of our strategy in driving deposit growth earlier in the third quarter was to get in front of the July Fed rate hike and lock in lower costs to replace the outflows from maturing deposits while still maintaining more than adequate liquidity. As I mentioned earlier, the weighted cost of new CDs during the third quarter was 5.14%, whereas the market is now pricing 12- to 24-month CDs between 5.6% and 6%. While we expect a certain percentage of maturing consumer and small business CDs to renew, we are not competitive in pricing in the institutional and public funds markets.
When combined with the broker deposit maturities, we do expect deposit and cash balances to be lower at the end of the year, which should have the added benefit of relieving some pressure on both our capital ratios and our net interest margin.
Looking at Slide 6, at quarter end, we estimate that our uninsured deposit balances were $948 million or 23% of total deposits, down slightly from 24% at the end of the second quarter. The decrease was driven primarily by the new CD production, which generally consisted of balances below the insured limit. As a reminder, included in the uninsured balance total are Indiana-based municipal deposits, which are insured by the Indiana Board for Depositories and neither require collateral nor are reported as preferred deposits on the bank’s call report, as well as certain larger balance accounts under contractual agreements that only allow withdrawal under certain conditions.
After adjusting for these types of deposits, our adjusted uninsured balances dropped to $704 million or 17% of total deposits, comparing favorably relative to the rest of the industry.
Moving to Slide 7, at quarter end, total liquidity remains very strong as we had cash and unused borrowing capacity of $1.7 billion. Our unused borrowing capacity increased during the quarter as we pledged additional collateral to the Federal Reserve. With the deposit growth over the course of the quarter, cash balances increased over $55 million. Furthermore, our loans-to-deposits ratio declined to 91.5%. At quarter end, our cash and unused borrowing capacity represents 182% of total uninsured deposits and 244% of adjusted uninsured deposits.
Turning to Slides 8 and 9, net interest income for the quarter was $17.4 million and $18.6 million on a fully taxable equivalent basis, down 4.2% and 4.4% respectively from the second quarter. The yield on average interest-earning assets increased to 5.02% from 4.89% in the linked quarter, due primarily to a 29 basis point increase in the yield earned on other earning assets, a 9 basis point increase in the average loan yield, and a 20 basis point increase in the yield earned on securities. The higher yields on interest-earning assets, combined with growth in average loan and cash balances, produced strong top-line growth in interest income, increasing over 8% compared to the linked quarter.
While deposit costs continued to rise, again, the pace of increase was the slowest in the past five quarters, and as a result, net interest income contraction was also the lowest in the past five quarters and in line with our expectations.
We reported a net interest margin of 1.39% in the third quarter, a decrease of 14 basis points from the second quarter. Fully taxable equivalent net interest margin for the quarter was 1.49%, down 15 basis points from the prior quarter. We estimate the higher cash balances we carried during the quarter negatively impacted net interest margin by 10 to 12 basis points.
The net interest margin rolled forward on Slide 9 highlights the drivers of change in fully taxable equivalent net interest margin during the quarter. Similar to this quarter, with higher-priced new loan originations and variable rate assets repriced higher for an entire quarter, we believe that we will deliver another increase in total interest income for the quarter. Currently, we expect the yield on the loan portfolio to be up around 20 to 25 basis points for the fourth quarter.
Furthermore, with short-term interest rates stabilizing and the repricing gap in CDs expected to narrow, we anticipate only a modest increase in interest-bearing deposit costs. With these expectations, combined with our forecast for a smaller balance sheet by year-end, and with the acknowledgement that some macroeconomic factors remain outside of our control, we continue to believe that the third quarter will represent the inflection point for net interest income and net interest margin, consistent with our comments from last quarter’s call.
Turning to non-interest income on Slide 10. Non-interest income for the quarter was $7.4 million, up $1.5 million from the second quarter.
Gain on sale of loans totaled $5.6 million for the quarter, up 14% over the second quarter, and consisted entirely of gain on sales of U.S. Small Business Administration 7(a) guaranteed loans. Our SBA team continued its track record of growth as sold loan volume increased 22% quarter-over-quarter, which was partially offset as net premiums were down 38 basis points.
Furthermore, the growth in our SBA business has resulted in a servicing portfolio approaching $500 million, which produced $800,000 of net servicing revenue during the quarter. Additionally, other income was up $500,000 from the linked quarter due primarily to distributions from fund investments. Looking at the bar chart of quarterly non-interest income, you can see that with the growth in our SBA business over the last several quarters, we have effectively backfilled and even exceeded any potential gap in revenue from exiting the mortgage business.
Moving to Slide 11, non-interest expense for the quarter was $19.8 million, up $1.1 million from the second quarter. The majority of the increase was in salaries and employee benefits, due primarily to higher benefit plan costs, as well as higher incentive compensation related to SBA and construction lending.
Loan expenses were up due mostly to higher third-party loan servicing fees and other miscellaneous lending costs. Data processing costs increased primarily because of variable deposit account opening costs, driven by the significant deposit growth earlier in the quarter. These increases were partially offset by declines in several other expense categories.
Turning to asset quality on Slide 2, David covered the major components of asset quality for the quarter in his comments. I will just add some color around the provision and the allowance for credit losses. The provision for credit losses in the third quarter was $1.9 million, compared to $1.7 million in the second quarter.
The provision for the third quarter reflects net charge-off activity during the quarter, additional specific reserves, and an increase in the reserve for unfunded commitments, partially offset by the positive impact of economic forecasts on loss rates and qualitative factors related to the allowance for credit losses for certain portfolios.
The allowance for credit losses as a percentage of total loans was 98 basis points as of September 30, compared to 99 basis points as of June 30. The decrease in the allowance for credit losses reflects the impact of certain economic data on forecasted loss rates and adjustments to qualitative factors on certain portfolios mentioned earlier, partially offset by higher coverage ratios in the C&I and SBA portfolios and additional specific reserves.
If you exclude the balances and reserves on our public finance and residential mortgage portfolios, which have modest coverage ratios given their lower inherent risk, the allowance for credit losses represented 1.17% of loan balances. Additionally, with minimal office exposure, we do not have the excess reserves around that asset class that many other banks have.
With respect to capital, as shown on Slide 13, our overall capital levels at both the company and the bank remained solid. The tangible common equity ratio declined 43 basis points to 6.64%. This was due to a combination of factors. First, like many other banks have experienced this quarter, our accumulated other comprehensive loss grew as interest rates increased at quarter end.
Second, we continued to repurchase shares throughout the quarter. And third, as David mentioned earlier, the tangible common equity ratio was impacted by deposit growth during the quarter and maintaining elevated cash balances. If you exclude accumulated other comprehensive loss and adjust for normalized cash balances of $300 million, the adjusted tangible common equity ratio would be 7.77%.
However, we do expect the balance sheet to shrink in the fourth quarter due to a decline in deposits and cash, which will have a beneficial impact on the tangible common equity ratio. From a regulatory capital perspective, the common equity Tier 1 capital ratio remains solid at 9.59%.
During the quarter, we repurchased over 97,000 shares of our common stock at an average price of $18.29 per share as part of our authorized stock repurchase program. In total, we have repurchased almost $41 million of stock under our authorized programs since November of 2021. At quarter end, tangible book value per share was $39.57, which is up over 3% on a year-over-year basis.
Before I wrap up my comments, I’d like to provide some additional comments on components of forward earnings. With regard to non-interest income, as our SBA team continues to grow and deliver consistently higher origination activity, we expect non-interest income to be in the range of $6.5 million to $7 million in the fourth quarter. However, two factors may affect our forecast. First, if the government shuts down in mid-November for an extended period of time, sales of SBA loans and the origination of new SBA loans will be halted.
And second, if we see a continued softening and gain on sale premiums, it may make economic sense to hold a loan yielding 11% or more versus selling for a premium far below the annual spread income we would earn. In connection with the continued increase in the level of SBA originations and additional back office personnel to support the increase, we do expect compensation expense to increase as well.
Therefore, we now expect total non-interest expense to be in the range of $20 million to $21 million for the fourth quarter. Looking toward the future, it is undeniable that there are macroeconomic and geopolitical forces beyond our control. Yet, we maintain confidence in our stalwart foundation remains firmly intact. Overall, asset quality is sound. Our capital position is strong. Our teams are focused. We believe we are well-positioned to improve our earnings and profitability profile as funding costs stabilize.
With that, I’ll turn it back to the operator so we can take your questions.
Question-and-Answer Session
Operator
Thank you. Ladies and gentlemen, we will now begin the question-and-answer session. [Operator Instructions] Your first question comes from Nathan Race from Piper Sandler. Please go ahead.
Nathan Race
Yes. Hey, guys, good afternoon. Thank you for taking my questions.
David Becker
Hey, Nate.
Ken Lovik
Hey, Nate.
Nathan Race
Just kind of want to clarify the margin outlook for the fourth quarter. I appreciate the guidance for loan yields up. I think it was 20 basis points to 25 basis points versus the third quarter, but it sounds like the margin pressure is going to continue, but should slow versus the pace of pressure from 2Q into 3Q. And then with the Fed remain on pause, hopefully we get some stability, if not expansion starting early next year. Is that the right way to think about the trajectory?
David Becker
Yes. I mean, as I said I think we think the inflection point is the third quarter. As we continue to optimize the loan book and pick up more yield there, I think with regards to deposit costs, especially with the CD re-pricing gap narrowing and frankly a lot of our deposits really tied to direct moves in Fed funds. I mean, we do not forecast deposit costs really increasing all that significantly in the fourth quarter. And again, notwithstanding forces outside our control, we expect net interest income, net interest margin to be up in the fourth quarter.
Larry Clark
Well, you’re spot on, Nate, and that is predicated on the Fed not bumping anything here in November, which indications are – they’re going to stay the course. So we got a shot. If you go back, as Ken made the comment, the excess cash on the balance sheet as that rolls off here this quarter, we think that will get us back in that positive vein. If we had not had the excess cash in the third quarter, we’d only had a compression on them of 300s of a point. So I think I agree with Ken, I think we’ve hit rock bottom on that compression and should start to see it expand here in the fourth quarter.
Nathan Race
Okay. And within that context, it sounds like the pipelines are in pretty good shape and loan growth should pick up in the fourth quarter. I apologize if you guys alluded to this earlier, but just in terms of what are loan growth expectations for the fourth quarter and perhaps even looking out to 2024 as well.
Ken Lovik
I mean I think we’ll probably continue to see loan growth in the fourth quarter similar to what we saw in the third quarter, maybe a little bit more. And again, to remind folks that we are some of our longer-term fixed rate portfolios, we’re kind of letting some of those really cash flow off and just replacing those balances with SBA franchise construction. So we’re obviously going to be able to pick up yield and optimize the portfolio
But fourth quarter probably similar to a bit more than the third quarter and looking into next year, some of the loan growth within individual line items will be pretty strong, but again, those will be offset by declines in others. So it could be mid single digit growth or mid to high single digit growth next year.
David Becker
The one caveat that could change that, as we were just talking a minute ago, Nate, is if the SBA either stops and we’re prohibited from selling, we do have a strong pipeline of loans here in the queue that will get closed here in the fourth quarter. If we put those on the balance sheet and that growth percentage is going to blow up pretty quickly. But as Ken said, we’re probably looking at 2% to 3% per quarter of loan growth going forward for the fourth quarter here as well as per quarter through 2024.
Nathan Race
And that’s not annualized growth per quarter.
David Becker
Annualized would be at about 9% to 10%, 2% to 3% per quarter annualized around 10%.
Nathan Race
Okay, yes, just clarifying there. And is the expectation, obviously you guys did a great job of growing deposits in the third quarter. Is the expectation that based on what you’re seeing in terms of new client wins and just where your pricing is across your products, that deposit growth can largely keep pace with loans going forward?
David Becker
Yes, we think it’ll keep pace with loans. We’ll actually see a little shrinkage here when some of the CDs roll off. One of the things we didn’t talk about in the call, but during the third quarter in particular, we rolled out some really nice features as add-ons to our small business checking accounts. We now have a forward looking cash forecast for them built into the product, as well as automated cash sweeps that they want to keep x balance in a checking account to move the rest to a money market. It’ll move both ways. They just set a balance at the end of the day. We’re really getting some good traction on that small business checking account.
We won an award last year of being one of the best in the country. And with the new features, we got a really nice new automated tool on the front end to help with the opening process. So, yes, that volume is picking up and that’s by far the cheapest funds that we have in the institution.
So, yes, continued growth there. We’re doing real well with the consumer, kind of post COVID small businesses and consumers learn that they really don’t need to have that traditional bank and our pricing and products are much better than the normal community banks. So we’re seeing nice pickup without a real ton of advertising and expense to go with it and it’s really worked well for us.
Nathan Race
Got you. If I could just ask a couple last questions on credit quality, particularly curious on the franchise growth. I mean, that’s been really impressive over the last year or so, balances up around 100%. Just curious in terms of underlying credit quality there. We’ve seen some issues within the franchise space thus far in earnings season. So just curious what you guys are seeing there in terms of any criticized migration and just kind of how comfortable you guys are growing that portfolio to a certain level going forward.
Ken Lovik
Yes, I mean, historically, I mean, to date, we’ve had 300,000 of charge offs. To date, we’ve had pretty good credit quality. I think it’ll probably – over time, there probably will be some charge offs there, but so far, I mean, to date, delinquencies have been very low. Continue to stay on top of it and monitor the portfolio, but I think probably like small business, there may be some pop ups here and there, but I don’t think there’s any – from our perspective, there’s no systemic real issues with the franchise to date.
David Becker
I actually set in on the Credit Committee Meeting this morning, and we had one account that was over 30 days, and we got a check in this morning that took them off the delinquency list. If it clears, we should end the month here with absolutely no delinquency in that portfolio. So, as Ken said, and historically apple pie has been around 10, 12, 13 years. Historically, they haven’t had about a 1.6% loss ratio, but so far we’re doing well.
Nathan Race
Got it. Great to hear. And then just lastly, in terms of the charge-offs this quarter, how much of it was related to the – I think it was a bank alliance loan that we’ve been talking about the last couple of quarters versus just kind of the small number of SBA loans that were called out in the press release.
Ken Lovik
You know what, the bank alliance deal was a couple quarters ago. We did have really the charge offs can be boiled down into two components, one piece of it being a handful of smaller SBA loans. And then we did charge off, we were a participant in a deal and the lead bank put the loan, pooled it as part of a larger pool of loan sales, and we worked with them on that, but we had to take a small charge as the sale price was less than the carrying value.
Nathan Race
Got it. So the C&I loan charge off in the third quarter was separate.
Ken Lovik
Yes, but it was not – to be clear, it had nothing to do with the bank alliance deal from earlier this year.
Nathan Race
Got you. And based on what you’re seeing across portfolio today, imagine, it’s fair to maybe expect some moderation charge off levels going forward.
David Becker
Yes. It’s an intriguing time, the bump up in interest rates, particularly on some of the older SBA loans that when we bought that first Colorado portfolio. Again, we discussed two or three in credit this morning that are getting deferments from the SBA world that will hopefully help them through the crunch. But we had people there that were at 3% from the beginning days of their loan that are now paying 11.5 to 12, and it is just putting a squeeze on them. But nothing systemic, no particular vertical in the lending area. That’s a problem, and I think we’ll continue to see some of these one off things, but stabilization and bumping the rates will help immensely, no question about it.
And if at some point in 2024, we start to see them go down, we’ll be in great shape. The SBA does have a lot of tools to help some of these smaller guys to go to an interest only basis to actually give them total payment deferment for 60, 90 days, up to six months in some cases. So we’re playing by the rules, and as I said, credit committee this morning numbers are still down over what we finished at quarter end, and looking good but who knows what might pop out?
Nathan Race
Got it. Makes sense. I appreciate the color. Thank you, guys. I’ll step back.
David Becker
Thank you.
Ken Lovik
Thanks, Nate.
Operator
Thank you. Your next question comes from Mike Perito from KBW. Please go ahead.
Unidentified Analyst
Hi, this is Mike’s associate Andrew filling in. Thanks for taking my questions.
David Becker
Sure.
Unidentified Analyst
I just wanted to start off here. I was wondering if you could give some more color on the back space. I know you commented on that new partnership you launched. I was just kind of wondering what’s the appetite look like for new partnerships and what kind of maybe revenue expectations can we see from some of the new partners you’ve onboarded in the last few quarters?
David Becker
Well, I was actually at Money20/20 on Tuesday. I heard that’s where Mike’s out there kind of running around as well. We had great meetings out there with all of our partners from increase to treasury prime to – we saw actually probably a half a dozen of the fintech companies that we’re working with. Most importantly, spent a fair amount of time with [indiscernible] So it’s looking good. Everything takes always a little longer than you think it’s going to get things up in line.But as Ken said in his comments, we had a nice boost up in deposits, the payment services side.
We’re processing over $1 billion a month in payments and still continuing to grow quite significantly month over month. Jaris [ph] I was hoping to have them live here kind of mid-month in October. We’ve got a couple T’s to cross and I’s to dot. We should be live by month in early November at the latest. So everything’s positive. We have a number of folks that we’ve been completing due diligence that are live and into pilot programs and are actually opening real accounts with real customer [indiscernible]. So it’s first quarter next year. It should be really, really strong and hopefully we’ll get a couple over the finish line and turn up some volume here in December.
Obviously, the credit card world shuts down. I think this year the blackout date is November 10. So we’re pressing real hard to get a couple through final due diligence in order to get their credit card systems moved and repointed our direction before November 10. So if that doesn’t happen, then it goes into mid-January before they reopen. But not a tremendous amount of impact here in the fourth quarter. But we could – I think first quarter next year, we’ll make as much as we did in the whole calendar year here of 2023.
Unidentified Analyst
Great. That sounds amazing. I appreciate the update. Maybe just jumping around a bit here. Could you provide a little color maybe around the ROA? Kind of what’s a reasonable target there for 2024 or kind of what the expectation is as some of these initiatives kind of pull through?
Ken Lovik
Yes. I mean, I think as we look into – I mean, I think we feel good about what next quarter looks like. And I think over the quarter of little over the course of next year in terms of like, NII, we should continue to see gradual improvement quarter by quarter. In terms of NIM improvement and NII improvement, we expect the SBA team to continue to grow next year as well. David talked about the BaaS initiatives and the revenue opportunities there. So I mean, I think, look, it’ll be a little bit lighter in the front end of the year, probably similar to fourth quarter, probably a little bit better than fourth quarter, maybe in the mid 40 basis point of ROA. But I think by the end of the year, by fourth quarter, we’re looking to be back up north of 80 and perhaps closer to 90 basis points.
Unidentified Analyst
Great. Appreciate that. And then just last question for me and then I’ll hop back. Any room for buybacks to accelerate here? I know there’s some good activity there in the third quarter. But maybe just is there any acceleration here in fourth quarter and then into 2024?
Ken Lovik
One of the things that we’re focused on, and we know the outside world pays a lot of attention to it the TCE. We fell under seven. Our goal is to get us back above seven at the current time at the price. We really can’t be out of the market on share repurchase, but we’re diligently paying attention to that 7%. If by chance the Fed does nothing and the long-term rates come back and AOCI drops down yes, we’ll stay in actively purchasing.
I think we’ll do something. I doubt that we’re going to expand much over what we did last quarter, particularly, hopefully the share price continues to climb as well as our numbers are getting better. So – but when we’re trading 30%, 40%, 50% a book, we can’t afford not to purchase shares back. But it’ll be a balancing act, really, kind of keeping an eye on TCE as well as the price of the shares. So we’re in the market, we’ll stay in the market. But it won’t be probably as aggressive as we were in the first half of the year, but we’ll stay out there.
Unidentified Analyst
Great. Thank you. That’s all for me. I appreciate all the color.
David Becker
Great. Thank you.
Ken Lovik
Thank you.
Operator
Thank you. Your next question comes from George Sutton from Craig-Hallum. Please go ahead.
George Sutton
Thank you. David, you mentioned in your script that you’ve grown to be the 9th largest SBA player. What is your goal? What is the governor to your growth? How much more can you expand in that area?
David Becker
George, we really don’t have any limitation out here. I think we’re going to finish this year at about 380. My guys will be beating on me here. But we haven’t forecasted for 440, 450. I think they got a real shot at 500 next year. And you’re going to be hearing phones drop all over the office here, the folks that are listening in on the call. But I wouldn’t be surprised to see us get pretty close to 500 million next year. As long as we’re selling 75% the insured portion and getting a good return on that. We’re in great shape. I would say we could run up to probably 1 billion on our internal portfolio and $0.25 on the dollar. That gives us a lot of room for new production.
So if we start bucking them and holding them on the balance sheet, that could slow down the gross number a little bit. But as Ken said a couple of minutes ago, we’re getting an 11.5%, 12% yield versus a 5% or something on the purchase side. It makes sense to hang on the balance sheet, but anything less than 1 billion, we have no qualms whatsoever in keeping it going.
George Sutton
And I wanted to make sure that I understood the 11% opportunity in terms of because you were couching it in the sense that the government could shut down and I think therefore would hold more. Was I hearing that correctly or what would motivate you to increase the amount that you’re holding?
David Becker
If the government closes, we’ll hold the assets because we can’t sell them in the secondary market if the government’s not there to make the transfer. So we’ll hang on to them. That could reopen if they’re down for a couple of days, it’ll reopen in a week to 10 days to get the machine oiled and back running, they’re down for 24 hours, they’re going to come right back. So might put a little lag in there.
The return, as Ken said, and I’m going to blow this up. So you can go back and fact check me, but we grew the sales by 20%, but the actual sales yield we got was down 30% over last quarter. If that continues to decline, if the market is saturated, a lot of banks across the country are not buying assets or boosting their balance sheets. So if the market falls off and I can only get a 5% or 6% purchase price, why would I sell an 11.5%, 12% asset? Because I’ll make that back up in 12 months. So it’s really two focuses. Government shutdown could slow it down as well as if the yields in the secondary market continues to soften. We’ll just keep them on the balance sheet.
George Sutton
Perfect. That’s it for me.
David Becker
Thank you, Sutton. Nice to hear from you.
Operator
Thank you. Your next question comes from John Rodis from Janney. Please go ahead.
John Rodis
That was close. Hey, good afternoon, guys.
David Becker
Hey, John.
Ken Lovik
Hi, John. How are you?
John Rodis
Good. Good, David, Ken. Ken, maybe just back – circling back to the margin. I think last quarter you talked about by the fourth quarter of next year, the margin could sort of be 190 to 195. Do you still think that’s possible?
Ken Lovik
Yes. I think there’s a pathway there. I mean, certainly into the 180-ish range and the upper bound of that, but yes, I think we still feel good about that outlook.
John Rodis
Okay. Okay. And again, you feel like this current – the third quarter was sort of the inflection for the margin and net interest income dollars.
Ken Lovik
That’s how we feel right now. Again, the caveat of things that are out of our control. But right now, at least with our forecasts [indiscernible] and what we saw, I think, as David said in his comments, we were – we probably hit bottom in July and August in terms on a monthly basis. And in September we had a nice rebound there. So the trajectory is already going up.
David Becker
Interest expense actually dropped September over August by over $400,000, and portion some higher cost funds walked out, and we shrunk cash just a little bit, but we really are leveling off, and when our peers are out here at 30 basis points, 40 basis points on CDs, having to buy in today’s market for 400 plus, as Ken said, our CD average out here now, what’s coming up for renewal is in a 440, 450 range, and if we pick them up at 490 at 30 basis point move to us, it’s going to be nonexistent. So we really, really do think we hit the bottom of the barrel on them compression.
John Rodis
Okay. Good. Ken, maybe just two other things on expenses, you upped the target $20 million to $21 million, would you still expect for next year sort of mid-single digit growth off of, I guess the fourth quarter level?
Ken Lovik
Yes, probably. Yes, that sounds, that’s about right.
John Rodis
And then also on the fee income side, I think last quarter you talked about growth of 15% to 20% next year, is that still sort of a good ballpark figure?
Ken Lovik
If they hit my $500 million number I just threw out, it’s going to be better than that.
John Rodis
I’d rather see you under promise and over deliver, David.
David Becker
Then book in the 440 that they’re telling me and you’ll be okay.
John Rodis
Yeah.
Ken Lovik
I think you’re okay with that assumption, John.
John Rodis
Okay. Okay. Okay, guys. Thank you.
Ken Lovik
Thank you.
David Becker
Appreciate it. John, sorry I missed your show, buddy. I had a conflict. I couldn’t get out of, but I’m sure Ken and Nicole did a great job.
John Rodis
No problem at all.
David Becker
All right. Thank you.
Operator
Thank you. Your next question comes from Brett Rabatin from Hovde Group. Please go ahead.
Brett Rabatin
Hey, guys. Good afternoon. Thanks for the questions.
David Becker
Hey Brett.
Brett Rabatin
Hey. I wanted to go back to the loan yields and you talked about 20 basis points to 25 basis points of improvement in the fourth quarter. They were up 9 basis points in 3Q. What’s the – can you talk about the loans that matured 3Q versus 4Q and then maybe if you have a maturity schedule for 24 out of the fixed bucket?
Ken Lovik
Yes. I think the loan yield; some of it is just timing of funding. The opportunity for us on the loan book is, again, we continue to let some of the lower stuff come off. And we have – we had good quarter-over-quarter growth in construction, but the timing of that was probably a little bit more weighted on the back end of the quarter. So that impacted the yields a little bit in terms of for the quarter. And then we had good production in franchise for the quarter. That sets us up for a good starting point for the fourth quarter. And obviously, the SBA balances were up as well.
So I just think with some of the production perhaps being a little bit more weighted in the back end of the third quarter, it sets us up really good for the fourth quarter in terms of loan yield improvement. I guess looking over the course of the next, let’s just call it the next 18 months, in terms of our variable rate loans are about 20% of our loan portfolio today. And then when you take into account what’s going to mature and also pay down in our fixed loan portfolio, I mean, we’re probably looking at almost $1.1 billion or so, about 30% of the loan book that’s going to turn over between now and the end of 2024.
So for us, a lot of the loans aren’t necessarily renewals. They just mature and they’re replaced with new loans or new borrowers. But as we remix and optimize the compensation, we’re just going to see a lot of good loan repricing and loan replacement, if you will over the next 15 months.
David Becker
A lot of our municipal portfolio also, Brett, has semiannual payments on it, so we get a big bump in June and we also get a big bump in December. We’ve got, I think this quarter, $20 million plus in repayment on the municipal loans and that’s the 2.5%, 3.5%, 4% paper, so that’ll help as well.
Brett Rabatin
Okay, that’s helpful. And then you guys talk about some of the CDs that are coming off the books and those rates versus the market CD rates that you’re seeing obviously in the 5%, and a 5.6%, where are you guys pricing CDs today and how does that contrast to the CDs that are rolling off the books here in the fourth quarter?
Ken Lovik
Right now we’re priced in that six to 12-month range in the upper fours and what’s going to be rolling off is going to be on the commercial side, it’s going to be about 5.5%, and on the consumer side it’s about 5.12%, 5.14%, so we should pick up 40 basis points, 50 basis points and plus we hope to reduce the outstanding cash. A lot of that’s going to roll during December. We have over $157 million, I think, coming up for maturity in the month of December and we’ll probably see about half of that go away, so it’s late in the quarter but it should still have an impact on our interest expense.
Brett Rabatin
Okay, and then just lastly, the DDA growth this quarter, can you talk about that and if that’s the start of a trend or if that was a function of particular clients or business?
Ken Lovik
Yes. Most of that growth and interest bearing demand is actually BaaS deposits, which we’ve been continuing to grow, obviously over the last two to three quarters, but most of that growth is BaaS within that category.
Brett Rabatin
Okay. What about the non-interest bearing piece, Ken?
Ken Lovik
The non-interest bearing, sometimes that can be a little bit volatile. Some of the – there can be some big balances that impact that because a lot of times in our construction business when the sponsor, the borrower puts equity into the deal upfront, they’ll put that into a non-interest bearing balance here and then that gets drawn down, but as we do more construction, it’ll go up. So that’s probably the biggest piece of any quarter-to-quarter movement in that line item.
David Becker
We also have some municipal sites that, Brett, like the City of Fishers here, come mid-November, they’ll have a big pop when they get property taxes in and that’ll set in a non-interest account for 30 days, 60 days until they get it reallocated, so there’s some seasonality in some of our municipal deposits.
Brett Rabatin
Okay, all really helpful. Thanks so much.
David Becker
Appreciate it, sir. Thank you. See you next week.
Brett Rabatin
See you next week, that’s right.
Operator
Thank you. There are no further questions at this time. I’ll hand it back to David Becker for closing remarks. Mr. Becker, you may proceed.
David Becker
Thank you, Sergio, and thanks everybody for joining us on today’s call. As we look forward to 2024 and beyond, we remain extremely excited about the future and the opportunities here. Strong performance in the commercial and consumer lending teams, including our growth in the small business construction lending and further growth opportunities with the fintech partnerships and banking as a service are expected to drive greater revenue growth, which combined with stabilized deposit costs. We believe will translate into the stronger earnings and the increased NIM over the course of the next year. As fellow shareholders, we remain committed to driving improved profitability and enhanced shareholder value, and we certainly thank you for your time today and have a good afternoon. We appreciate it. Thanks.
Operator
Ladies and gentlemen, this concludes your conference call for today. We thank you for participating and ask that you please disconnect your lines. Thank you.
Read the full article here