Oil prices settle lower for a second day as investors gauge Israel-Gaza war for supply threat

Israel isn’t a major oil producer, but investors are focused on whether the conflict escalates.

Read: Israel-Gaza war scenarios: what might lift oil prices to $95, $100, and $115 a barrel

“The risk to the world’s crude oil supply is low for now,” said Brian Swan, senior commodity analyst at Schneider Electric, in a daily note. “However, there is a small chance for prices to rise because the United States is looking closely at Iran’s connection with Hamas. If the U.S. decides to impose stricter limits on Iran’s crude oil exports, it could affect how the market looks.”

The Wall Street Journal on Sunday reported that Iranian military officials helped plan and coordinate the Hamas attack. White House national security adviser Jake Sullivan has described Iran as “complicit” in the attacks, having long provided funding and training to Hamas, but has said the U.S. so far hasn’t had confirmation Tehran had advance knowledge of the attack.

On Wednesday, the New York Times reported that the U.S. has collected multiple pieces of intelligence showing that key Iranian leaders were surprised by the Hamas attack in Israel.

Iranian oil exports had fallen sharply after the Trump administration withdrew the U.S. from a nuclear accord with Tehran in 2018 and reimposed sanctions. Production and exports have since recovered partially, with output hitting 3.1 million barrels a day this summer, according to data cited by Commerzbank. Exports were estimated to have recovered to around 2 million barrels a day.

“Before the attacks, the U.S. had adopted a softer posture toward Iran, allowing it to approach pre-2018 levels of oil production,” said Hakan Kaya, senior portfolio manager at Neuberger Berman, in an emailed blog post. “However, given recent events and Iran’s known support for Hamas, the U.S. may adopt a stricter stance, potentially leading to a reduction in Iranian oil supply.”

The recent attacks have also decreased the chances of a “near-term normalization of Saudi-Israeli relations,” Kaya said, noting that before last weekend’s developments, Saudi Arabia has reportedly expressed willingness to boost oil production if crude prices remained high.

The latest developments “could potentially affect Saudi oil production plans, leading them to extend their existing cuts for a longer period, which could further deplete already low global oil inventories,” he said.

Read: Here’s what Israel-Gaza war means for oil prices as fighting continues

In a note, analysts at ING wrote that “if the conflict is contained to Israel and Hamas we would expect the current risk premium to slowly erode. However, there is still a risk that this escalates, particularly if there is any Iranian involvement.”

Under that scenario, stronger enforcement of U.S. sanctions on Iranian oil would tighten up the oil market through 2024,” they said.

In a monthly report released Wednesday, the Energy Information Administration forecast an average 2024 price of $90.91 a barrel for WTI oil, up 9.2% from the September forecast. Brent crude is expected to average $94.91 next year, up 7.6% from the previous forecast.

The government agency said global crude-oil supply growth has been limited this year because of voluntary production cuts from Saudi Arabia and reduced output targets from other OPEC+ countries.

Also read: EIA expects a decline in this year’s U.S. natural-gas heating bills

Meanwhile, energy traders digested news that Exxon Mobil Corp.
XOM,
-0.01%
plans to buy Pioneer Natural Resources Co.
PXD,
-0.03%
for about $59.5 billion in stock.